Sam wasn’t making any ground with Andi in Reaper episode 9, so as luck would have it, he hit it off well with the Devil’s mistress’ daughter Cady, who may or may not be the Devil’s daughter as well.
Cady and Sam are dating now. She shows up to see him and says there’s been a death in the family: her pet goldfish. A pet goldfish that she pulls out of her pocketbook to show him. The boys show up and want him to ask her if she’s the spawn of Satan. She thinks they’re nice but overprotective, and they’re not afraid to dance with each other just to keep a closer eye on her.
Andi wants to know what’s wrong with her. They tell her the truth. For some reason, she finds it hard to believe.
The Devil fakes Sam out, pretending to be Cady, and calls him to talk about enjoying being naked and biting the heads off live chickens.
Two robbers got into an argument over the money they stole 14 years ago and shot each other dead. One of them’s back from Hell and has a multi-million dollar home with the money, which was never found by the authorities.
Sam, Sock, and Ben go to the new house, pretending to test for radon. As usual, the use of the vessel, a lighter this time, is poorly planned, and the soul escapes by running through a wall. They catch up to him, and he offers to make them rich. He says there’s more where that came from and pulls out a box… that contains a gun. He shoots, but Sam reacts and sucks him into the lighter. He wasn’t lying, though, there really was plenty more where that came from, and they find a box of money where the rest was.
The vessel has been rejected. They must fill out a form. Typical response time is 6-8 weeks.
Sock and Ben believe they’re entitled to the money. Sam’s not convinced and wants to do the right thing with the $6 million in stolen cash.
Cady never knew her father, who she suggests was part of Huey Lewis.
The Devil tells Sam the vessel was only half full (or half empty). The second criminal broke out of Hell, too. Not one to beat around the bush, the Devil warns Sam that the second soul is the dangerous one. Oh, and he should spend the stolen money.
Sock and Ben broke into Sam’s room to take some of the money and spend it. Sam’s afraid they’ll end up like the two robbers, killing each other over the money. They agree to not spend any more. Sock then reveals he burnt down Josie’s apartment shortly before they broke up and has now bought everything that burned in that fire. He’s just trying to make amends but would be happy if she were to thank him in a naked or partially naked way.
They find out there was a third robber, one who’s still alive and was sentenced to 10 years in prison. He’s out now, so they go to where he works but find out he was hauled off for something to do with a bank robbery.
Sock comes up with a plan to prove Cady’s the Devil’s daughter: finding a 666 on her body. He saw it in a movie. She thinks they’re just trying to protect Sam and promises she’s not going to steal him from them. Sock asks to see her naked… not because they want to but because they have to. Her counteroffer: they need to get naked, too. They agree and don’t see a 666, so apparently now she is Devil free.
The third robber is now free again. He was a bank manager but had a gambling problem. He met up with the robbers and thought they were fun, but they were just setting him up. He claims he was framed but that nobody believed him, not even his family.
Sock brings Josie what he bought for her with the money. She immediately thinks it’s stolen merchandise. Of course it’s not stolen merchandise. The money was just stolen. She’s not interested in his gifts.
Ben and Sam ask Ted, who used to have a gambling problem (and apparently still does), where they could find some high rollers. They slap a stack of money and say the need for $10K just to get in is no problem. He’ll take them if they stake him.
Josie goes to Andi and is suspicious that something must be up because the boys are acting strangely all the time. Andi’s noticed it, too.
Ted doesn’t last long before being assaulted, but the others stick around to gamble. They sit down at the soul’s table and wait for him to get sick of them. He leaves when they slap down money that he recognizes, and he goes through the wall, taking Ben with him. He threatens to kill Ben if they don’t bring him the rest of his money.
They bring a bag and set it on fire. It’s not money, though, just Sock’s underpants. The soul falls for it, and they capture him as he’s distracted.
They decide they don’t want the money any more and leave it at the donut shop where the ex-bank manager works. The Devil warns Sam he’ll just waste the money gambling and will be homeless in a year. While they’re talking, Cady walks in, and she admits to Sam that she doesn’t actually know who her father is and that it may be the Devil. Sam wants to convince her otherwise. As the flowers wilt behind them, he can’t figure out why she keeps unintentionally killing things, though.
Stay tuned to dingoRUE for another live recap of Reaper episode 11.