In The Bachelorette 4 Episode 9 DeAnna Pappas got over Graham. And decided that she was in love with the other three but not in love with him any more. Apparently. She’s also over Brad. Apparently. (Even though we hear his name every 5 minutes.) Anyway, between the three remaining guys, Jeremy ended up getting the boot, which brings us down to the final two: Jason Mesnik and Jesse Csincsak. Jason struck me as one of the clear frontrunners from the beginning of the season, although I am surprised to see Jesse having made it this far. We found out last week that DeAnna is indeed engaged this time around, so now it’s just a matter of finding out who The Bachelorette 4 winner is.
Now DeAnna will be introducing both guys to her big fat Greek family. She’s warned the boys that her family plans to be mean this time around because of Brad (yeah, I’ve heard his name 5 times in the last 20 seconds). Jason arrives at the house first with flowers for DeAnna and her family. He says that he doesn’t blame them for grilling him, so they might as well just get to it. Her father’s not sure she’s ready to be immediately moving into a family. DeAnna’s sister Chrissy wants to know whether he’s in love and ready to get married, and he says he’s never felt like this, including during his first marriage. Then Jason asks her father for permission to propose, and he gets a response that nobody’s ever asked that before. Her dad gives him his blessing if DeAnna should choose him.
Jesse’s up next. He’s visibly nervous. He got his haircut at least. Her father’s concerned that his pro snowboarding career doesn’t have a great deal more time left in it. Jesse has had a two year relationship in which he lived with his girlfriend, but he says that this is all new to him. DeAnna’s sister immediately liked Jason but doesn’t really get to know anything about Jesse during his time there, which turns out to be three very unproductive hours. Her father’s not so sure that Jesse’s really in love, whereas he feels that Jason was heartfelt.
Day two is no longer just the immediate family. The crowd there will be more than twice the size of yesterday’s. Jesse shows up first. Then Jason shows up. Yeah, who came up with this really stupid idea? Awkward for everybody involved. DeAnna’s grandmother tells Jason she prefers him. Jesse seems to be doing better this time than he did the day before, and he even asks for permission from her father. DeAnna walks the boys to the car, holding hands with both of them at the same time as she’s been doing for much of the day. Jesse wants to make sure he gets the last hug in, so he lets her say goodbye to Jason first. Chrissy is not sure that Jesse’s ready for a commitment. DeAnna’s other sister Crystal prefers Jesse because he’s a free spirit who is not as grown up as Jason (just like DeAnna’s not as grown up as Jason).
A former bachelor’s back. No, not Brad, although that would be interesting. Jeremy has returned to confront DeAnna. He tells her she’s making a big mistake but acknowledges that he hasn’t really let her see him. She says that he’s a perfect guy, but that she just doesn’t love him. Since she’s not in love with him yet, she can’t drag it on any further. It takes some convincing, but he finally takes the hint, although he’s still in love with her.
DeAnna’s got one last set of dates before making her decision. Jesse’s up first, and they take a ride on a seaplane to a secluded island. He’s put together a book of thoughts for her, a photo album that he reads to her, and he wants her to know he’s ready to spend the rest of his life with her. As usual, she doesn’t say anything in return, which she says is because she doesn’t want to mislead anybody. Kinda silly because somebody’s getting misled regardless.
Jason gets the final date, and they will be swimming with the sharks. He loves that she takes him on these crazy adventures (thought of and paid for by ABC). He, too, has a surprise. It’s a boardgame that he’s made himself, which allows them to relive their dates throughout this experience. The game ends in him telling her he loves her and wants to spend the rest of his life with her.
On decision day, as Jason gets down on one knee to propose, DeAnna stops him, saying “No, I can’t.” She’s in love with somebody else. I can’t be alone in saying I’m surprised by that.
We know what happens next. DeAnna will be getting and accepting a proposal from Jesse. For the first time this season, she finally tells someone she’s in love with them, instead of just sitting there nodding.
I’m pretty much just confused by this ending, but it beats what happened on The Bachelor 11.
Next up, we find out what happens after the final rose.