The Biggest Loser 4 Episode 9 saw yet another reshuffling, this time into duos. Despite her initial fear of being partnered with Amy, Kae narrowly escaped the chopping block. It came down to a vote between Isabeau and Ryan, and Ryan was sent packing.
The whole duo thing didn’t last very long. We’re now down to every player for themselves.
Bob gets upset at Neil’s vote against Ryan, despite the fact that he says he discussed the plan with Ryan.
Amy completes throwing Kim away, trading in her red shirt for a black one. Kim expresses her disappointment and asks Amy to keep the shirt, but she’s not interested.
Donuts, donuts, and more donuts. It’s a temptation. Inside one of the donuts is a token worth $5,000. I was initially thinking this wouldn’t be worth it, but they only have to eat one donut per round, with each round lasting a minute and allowing them to search through as many as they can. As with the Reese’s, Amy’s a little too happy to see this food. Also as with last time, Kae passes up the opportunity. I think she’s a little too hardcore at this dieting thing, but the rest of these people should take notes, as this is why she keeps blowing them out of the water. Nicole sits out of the second round. Round three has no time limit. Julie drops out regardless because she’s met her calories. Isabeau came within inches of finding the token but missed it, leaving a door open for Bill to win the money, to go along with the SUV he won last week.
The challenge is a 24k (15 miles) triathlon. The first 6 to bike 20k on the stationary bikes will move onto treadmills, where the first three to run 3k will move to the pool, where the first person to swim 1k wins. The prize is a 24 hour trip home. In addition, because they will be home for a full day, the winner will receive immunity, a particularly big deal for targets like the guys and Kae. Lastly, the winner will make a big decision, which won’t be revealed until after the challenge.
Kae’s first to both 5k and 10k. Isabeau’s pretty well out of it, while Amy, Neil, Julie and Bryan fight for the last two spots behind Hollie, Nicole, and Bill. With 3k left, Nicole starts to give Kae a run for her money. Bill and Hollie are still close behind. Isabeau, Julie, and Amy are now out of it, leaving Neil and Bryan looking in good shape to take the final two slots. Kae finishes first. Nicole is second. Bill is third. Hollie is fourth. Bryan is fifth. Neil takes sixth. Julie at 18k and Amy and Isabeau at 17k are eliminated.
Kae is first to hit .5k on the treadmill. She retains the lead throughout, hitting 2.5k first as well. Bill and Hollie are the second and third to hit 2.5k, but Bryan is close behind them. Kae finishes first. Bill finishes second. Hollie finishes third, inching out Bryan, and she’s confident in her swimming ability because she’s a swim coach. Nicole, Bryan, and Neil are eliminated at the 2.5k mark.
Kae, Bill, and Hollie move to the pool, where they will swim 40 lengths. It’s pretty obvious what’s going to happen here. Kae’s dominance in the first two events will be completely meaningless, as Hollie who barely made it through will win due to her swimming experience. Poorly designed competition, particularly bad considering how high the stakes are. Hollie wins, Bill comes in second with 30 laps, Kae finishes third with 26 laps.
In addition to the rewards, Hollie must now pick another person to give the reward to as well. Again pretty obvious what will happen. Perhaps not exactly who, but it’ll be a black team member, one of the girls, meaning Isabeau or Julie. She chooses Julie. Considering Bill did so well in the challenge, whereas Julie dropped out right away, I’d think it would have made more sense to choose him, not only picking a teammate but also reducing the ability for people to be upset that she’s playing favorites. They’re left with a warning: if they’ve gained weight at the next weigh-in, they will no longer have immunity.
Hollie goes home to see her best friend, who says she’s inspired her to start losing weight as well. Julie goes home to see her son and husband, who himself has started to lose weight, now down 28 pounds. Both women have to cope with food choices in the real world. Julie chooses to do the Subway commercial, which actually if you have to eat fast food is the best alternative, though they do have plenty of menu items that aren’t so healthy. Hollie has a salad with dressing on the side but also gets pizza, which is a bad choice even without cheese, though as she said it’s not bad once in a while. Then it’s time to exercise. Julie wears her husband out on the beach. Hollie takes her friend to the gym.
When Jillian walks in the room, Amy’s crying. Still.
Julie: 180 pounds (no change)
Hollie: 212 pounds (no change)
Julie takes the lack of change as an indication she has a lot to learn. Her worst week previously was a 2 pound loss in week 2. Hollie’s previous worst performance was also a 2 pound loss. I don’t think either of them should have immunity still. With no change, the cards should fall where they may, particularly since both should lose a lot of weight next week.
Bill: 234 pounds (-8, 3.31%)
Bill becomes the second person this season to lose 100 pounds.
Nicole: 222 pounds (-7, 3.06%)
Neil: 311 pounds (-10, 3.12%)
Amy: 242 pounds (-3, 1.22%)
Isabeau: 241 pounds (-5, 2.03%)
Bryan: 276 pounds (-2, 0.72%)
Kae: 159 pounds (-4, 2.45%)
So it comes down to Amy and Bryan. Isabeau raises a concern that Amy’s complaining too much about wanting to go home as she has from day one. Isabeau says she thinks Amy’s a threat, to which Jillian responds, “Are you kidding?” Bill weighs in as well. Comparing the weight losses, he says Amy is beating Bryan (not exactly true, but Bryan is indeed down there close to Amy toward the bottom of the weight loss percentages). He says his vote doesn’t matter anyway because Isabeau’s already voting for Amy. Neil, without having the issue of whether he’s black team or not, says Amy deserves to go home.
Votes
Nicole: Amy
Kae: Amy
Neil: Amy
Julie: Bryan
Hollie: Bryan
Bill: Bryan
Isabeau: Amy
I’m quite surprised by this move, but I’m all for it. As big a fan as I am of gameplay on shows like this, Amy got to an enough is enough stage of this competition quite some time ago. Unlike the classy exit speeches we’ve come to expect, Amy says karma’s a bitch and that the black team can’t trust Isabeau. Get off my screen already. This was at least a chance to redeem herself for all the complaining she’s done under both Kim and Jillian, but she couldn’t even get this part right. Today, Amy is down 100 pounds to 197 from her original weight of 297.
Stay tuned to dingoRUE for another recap of The Biggest Loser 4 episode 11, which airs Tuesday at 8/7c on NBC.