After Carolyn used her idol, Dan was sent packing in Survivor: Worlds Apart Episode 13, as her alliance’s votes against her did not count. That brings us down to a final five of Carolyn Rivera, Mike Holloway, Rodney Lavoie Jr., Sierra Dawn Thomas, and Will Sims II.
I agree with Probst that this was a good season for people who are trying to play the game. Unfortunately, it’s also been a good season for very unlikeable and unnecessarily volatile cast members. This seems to be Mike’s to lose, perhaps to Carolyn. Rodney has been a hothead. Will has been inept and invisible. And Sierra, I was surprised to learn her last name is not Who?
Mike can’t figure out why Carolyn is going to the beach with the people who all just voted against her. She has an explanation. He may have joined with her, but he does not have the numbers. So she doesn’t care that they just tried to eliminate her. Mike remains her target.
Reward is a camp visit with a loved one plus an advantage in the immunity challenge. Their task is to go through a net crawl, slide tiles on a platform, transport those tiles on a machete across some obstacles, and lastly use them to solve a puzzle. As usual, Mike s in the lead. Nobody else is even seeming competitive. Mike wins reward.
Mike’s advantage is that his mom can lead him through the maze while he is blindfolded for 30 minutes. They are all blindfolded during the challenge of searching for medallions in the maze, so he is the only one with even limited visual guidance in the task. Once again, Mike takes the lead and quickly begins to blow everyone else away. It gets to the point where everybody else starts helping each other, but it’s too little, too late. Mike wins immunity.
Now that Mike’s immune, Carolyn has changed her mind. She’s his buddy now and wants to get rid of Rodney. Sierra is onboard with this plan because she’s also afraid of Mike.
The other name up for consideration is Sierra. Her defense to keep her: she hasn’t won anything, but she keeps coming in second to Mike. Jeff poses the question: isn’t that a reason to get rid of her?
Votes
Sierra
Rodney
Sierra
Sierra
With 3 votes, Sierra has been voted off the island.
For the last time, immunity is back up for grabs. It is not an endurance challenge, a fact that may be Mike’s saving grace. They run up stairs to grab a bag, slide down a waterslide or at least a slide with water on it, go through an obstacle course, and repeat the process two more times before opening those bags to use the pieces to solve a puzzle. Do I even have to mention that Mike is in the lead? Mike wins immunity for the fifth time.
The logical choice here would seem to be for Mike to bring Rodney and Will to the end with him because they can’t beat anybody. Granted, I can’t see Carolyn winning either, but she seems a lot more likely to actually get some votes. Rather than doing the logical thing, Mike has an alternate plan to force a tie and send it to a fire making challenge. I could perhaps understand the rationalization to this if she had been on his side, but she turned against him immediately after the vote in which they tried to get rid of her. Of course, this is Mike we’re talking about. He’s not here because he’s a strategic mastermind. He’s here because he kept winning challenges.
Votes
Rodney
Carolyn
Carolyn
Rodney
We have a tie. After 6 minutes, Carolyn breaks her flint, so she gets a new one. Rodney eventually does the same and then a second time. Carolyn, too. The jury is bored and shaking their heads. Rodney finally makes flame after 45 minutes, but it doesn’t last. He’s figured it out and gets fire again. Carolyn gets it, too, but her fire is quite unimpressive relative to his. Unlike Rodney, Carolyn is building a fire slowly but one that is effective. Rodney has been eliminated. He leaves swearing at Mike.
Joe claims to be an open book, but he doesn’t have any questions, just an explanation of what he wants them to do when others ask them questions.
Hali asks Carolyn about her mother role, which she acknowledges but says she also fought hard.
Rodney talks to his best bud Will, who talks about only having what he is as a person. Then he asks Carolyn about what moves she’s made, and she provides examples of Tyler’s elimination and the alliance she was forced into at the end with Mike.
Tyler asks about Mike’s social game, and Mike acknowledges that he didn’t do a good job at that, as bitter people like Dan respond with a head shake. He then asks Carolyn to redeem herself in his eyes, and she apologizes but hey, this is Survivor.
Sierra asks which trait they’d like from the other two players. Will appreciated Mike’s work ethic.
Jenn doesn’t have any problem with the final three. Instead, she wants to bash the jury for being bitter and angry. Classic Jenn. And to recap, vote for Mike.
Dan accuses Mike of not caring about the jury. That is all. Only not really. He asks Jeff if he can get back up and run his mouth some more, but this time he has some kinder words for Mike after hearing him defend himself.
Shirin just wants to talk more about how Will upset her.
Votes
Mike
Will
Carolyn
Mike
Mike
Mike
Will received Rodney’s vote, and Carolyn received Sierra’s vote. Otherwise, it looks like a landslide, as the Survivor: Worlds Apart winner is Mike. I’m not sure the right person did or did not win, but I’m not sure there necessarily was a right person. Still, this seems like a satisfactory ending.
As the winner, Mike is not eligible for next season, which he would have been part of otherwise.
Now it’s time to reveal the case for season 31 from the public vote.
Abi-Maria Gomes (Philippines, Season 25, 5th place)
Andrew Savage (Pearl Islands, Season 7, 10th place)
Ciera Eastin (Blood vs. Water, Season 27, 5th place)
Jeff Varner (Outback, Season 2, 10th place)
Jeremy Collins (San Juan del Sur, Season 29, 10th place)
Joe Anglim (Worlds Apart, Season 30, 10th place)
Kass McQuillen (Cagayan, Season 28, 3rd place)
Kelley Wentworth (San Juan del Sur, Season 29, 14th place)
Kelly Wigglesworth (Borneo, Season 1, 2nd place)
Kimmi Kappenberg (Outback, Season 2, 12th place)
Keith Nale (San Juan del Sur, Season 29, 4th place)
Monica Padilla (Samoa, Season 19, 7th place)
Peih-Gee Law (China, Season 15, 5th place)
Shirin Oskooi (Worlds Apart, Season 30, 8th place)
Spencer Bledsoe (Cagayan, Season 28, 4th place)
Stephen Fishbach (Tocantins, Season 18, 2nd place)
Tasha Fox (Cagayan, Season 28, 6th place)
Terry Deitz (Panama, Season 12, 3rd place)
Vytas Baskauskas (Blood vs. Water, Season 27, 10th place)
Woo Hwang (Cagayan, Season 28, 2nd place)
If I had to pick my Survivor dream cast, I’m not sure any of these people would be on it. Jeff talks up how this cast includes people from seasons 1-30, which he is right about, but more than half the cast is from the past 2 years, seasons that have not been interesting enough to warrant that high a concentration of castaways. As far as placement, there are a few runners up, but the average is 6.6, with a number of mediocre players in the mix. In fairness, some of the game’s best players didn’t make it very far on their first attempt.